> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.reputation-insider.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Canadian contractor says Google kept 13 disputed ratings while positive reviews disappeared
- URL: https://www.reputation-insider.com/canadian-contractor-says-google-kept-13-disputed-ratings-while-positive-reviews-disappeared/
- Published: 2026-11-15T09:50:40.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-15T09:52:23.000Z
- Description: A Canadian contractor says 13 allegedly fake one-star Google ratings remained online three weeks after being reported, while 10 of 19 new five-star reviews disappeared. The company's public rating stood at 2.7 stars.
- Author: Levi Mastarel
- Tags: Watchlist, #watchlist-main, #hide-recent

A Canadian construction business has publicly questioned Google's review moderation after 13 allegedly fraudulent one-star ratings remained visible while positive reviews from what the owner describes as genuine customers disappeared. In a [Google Business Profile Community complaint](https://support.google.com/business/thread/477669100/13-fake-one-star-reviews-still-up-after-3-weeks-while-google-deletes-our-real-customer-reviews?hl=en&ref=reputation-insider.com), the owner of Gritwell, a tiling and carpentry company in Pickering, Ontario, reported both problems on November 14.

According to the owner, the business received 14 one-star ratings over approximately 48 hours on October 21–22, having previously accumulated just one five-star review. The owner said none of the negative reviewers were customers and that several written complaints concerned a parking dispute near a place of worship, unrelated to the company's construction work.

01 / 02

## Nine disputed reviews were escalated while four remained pending

The business reported all 14 negative ratings to Google on October 22, classifying 12 as spam and two as off-topic. One rating was removed two days later, but the owner said the remaining 13 were still publicly visible more than three weeks after the complaints.

According to the post, nine of those reviews were marked *Escalated* in Google's review management tool and were no longer eligible for an appeal through the interface. The remaining four continued to display *Decision pending*, leaving the owner uncertain about how to obtain a further review of the complaints.

Google's [review-removal guidelines](https://support.google.com/business/answer/4596773?ref=reputation-insider.com) state that reported reviews are normally evaluated within several days. The company removes content that violates its policies but does not delete negative feedback solely because a business disputes its accuracy.

The public complaint does not establish that the disputed ratings violated Google's rules. The reviewers' identities and the business's customer records have not been independently examined.

02 / 02

## Ten positive reviews reportedly disappeared within days

The owner said 19 customers submitted five-star reviews between November 4 and November 10\. By November 14, ten had disappeared from the company's profile, including some containing detailed written feedback.

The business described the removals as occurring in stages, with some reviews initially withheld from publication before disappearing entirely. The owner also reported losing an existing response to one of the removed reviews.

At the time of the complaint, Gritwell's public profile reportedly displayed 23 reviews and an average rating of 2.7 stars. That total included the 13 disputed one-star ratings and ten five-star reviews.

Google acknowledges in its [documentation on missing reviews](https://support.google.com/business/answer/10313341?ref=reputation-insider.com) that automated systems can occasionally remove legitimate customer feedback. Reviews may also be delayed or removed when Google's systems identify suspected policy violations.

A participant in the community discussion suggested that the sudden increase in positive reviews might have triggered automated filtering. That explanation was speculative, and no public statement from Google established why the company's reviews had disappeared.

The owner requested that a Google product expert examine the negative ratings as a potentially coordinated incident and arrange a human review. The business offered to provide screenshots and customer records privately, but the available discussion does not document a final resolution.

The case rests on the owner's account of the review history and moderation status. It does not establish a wider pattern of incorrect removals or demonstrate that Google's systems deliberately treated positive and negative feedback differently.