> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.reputation-insider.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Meta, TikTok and Google oppose Indonesia's AI copyright proposal
- URL: https://www.reputation-insider.com/meta-tiktok-and-google-oppose-indonesias-ai-copyright-proposal/
- Published: 2026-11-11T18:59:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-14T13:11:23.000Z
- Description: The proposed changes would require payments to news publishers and introduce new copyright rules for artificial intelligence, prompting objections over news access and platform liability.
- Author: Levi Mastarel
- Tags: Watchlist, #watchlist-main, #hide-recent

Meta and TikTok have joined Google in challenging proposed revisions to Indonesia's copyright law that would require digital platforms to compensate news publishers for displaying their content. Representatives of the three companies raised objections during a parliamentary hearing in Jakarta, as lawmakers consider extending copyright protections to artificial intelligence and online content distribution.

According to [Reuters](https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/meta-tiktok-join-google-push-back-indonesias-planned-ai-copyright-law-revisions-2026-11-11/?ref=reputation-insider.com), the proposed legislation could make Indonesia the first Southeast Asian country to explicitly address AI within its copyright framework. The changes remain under parliamentary discussion, and the provisions have not been enacted.

01 / 02

## Google and Meta challenge mandatory payments for news links

Agung Pamungkas, Google's government affairs and public policy manager in Indonesia, told lawmakers that requiring platforms to compensate publishers for displaying links to news articles could restrict public access to information. His objection concerned the proposed treatment of links and content previews, which search engines use to direct readers to publishers' websites.

Meta's Indonesian public policy head, Berni Moestafa, raised similar concerns about the commercial consequences for news organizations. He argued that mandatory payments could reduce referral traffic and consequently affect publishers' advertising and subscription revenue.

Moestafa also distinguished between providing a link to an article and reproducing the article itself. The companies' arguments challenge the scope of the proposed compensation requirement, although their predictions about reduced readership have not been established as consequences of the Indonesian legislation.

The dispute follows earlier consultations involving Google and Indonesia's Press Council. According to the country's [Directorate General of Intellectual Property](https://dgip.go.id/index.php/artikel/detail-artikel-berita/djki-bahas-usulan-google-dan-dewan-pers-soal-hak-cipta?kategori=pengumuman&ref=reputation-insider.com), discussions covered the economic rights associated with journalism and compensation for the digital use of news content.

The Press Council proposed allowing publishers to choose between collective rights management and direct commercial agreements with platforms. That position reflects a separate concern about how news organizations would receive compensation and retain flexibility in negotiating distribution arrangements.

02 / 02

## TikTok seeks narrower AI disclosure requirements

TikTok focused its objections on provisions governing AI-generated content and the responsibilities of platforms hosting material uploaded by users. Noudhy Valdryno, the company's Indonesian public policy head, argued that disclosure obligations should distinguish between material created entirely by AI and work in which AI is used only as an assisting tool.

Valdryno also urged lawmakers to preserve existing safe-harbour protections for digital platforms. He argued that services hosting user-generated content cannot reliably establish whether every uploaded work is protected by copyright or whether its creator has obtained the necessary licences.

An earlier version of the legislation, [reported by Reuters](https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/indonesias-copyright-rewrite-puts-google-ai-platforms-notice-2026-07-17/?ref=reputation-insider.com), included provisions concerning copyrighted material used to train AI models. The draft also addressed the legal protection of AI-assisted works, although the precise requirements remain subject to revision.

Indonesian lawmakers have separately raised concerns about creators' work being used commercially without permission. In its [official account of the parliamentary hearing](https://emedia.dpr.go.id/news/2026/11/12/baleg-dorong-perlindungan-karya-kreator-dari-pemanfaatan-tanpa-izin?ref=reputation-insider.com), the legislature described questions about the unauthorized use of photographs and music in promotional material distributed through social platforms.

The copyright bill remains under consideration, with lawmakers continuing to receive submissions from technology companies and rights holders. Its final provisions have not been settled, and the objections raised by the companies do not establish which amendments parliament will accept.