Skip to content

Trump gets more time to testify in $10 billion BBC defamation case

A Florida judge has extended Donald Trump’s deadline for a sworn deposition in his lawsuit over the BBC’s misleading edit of his Capitol riot speech. Both sides agreed to more time for evidence gathering, while the defamation claim remains active after a separate claim was dismissed.

Trump gets more time to testify in $10 billion BBC defamation case

A US federal judge has given President Donald Trump additional time to testify under oath in his defamation lawsuit against the BBC, granting a joint request from the two sides to extend pretrial evidence gathering. District Judge Jeffrey Kuntz in Florida ruled that Trump must complete his deposition by January 22, 2027, moving the deadline back by approximately six weeks.

The revised court timetable also extends the discovery period until January 29 and requires both parties to be ready for trial by May 3. The lawsuit concerns a BBC documentary that combined separate passages from a speech Trump delivered before the US Capitol riot. The broadcaster has acknowledged that the editing was misleading and apologized, while maintaining that the mistake does not make it legally liable for defamation.

01 / 03

Trump receives an extension after both parties request more time

The president had previously been ordered to appear for a deposition by December 11 after the BBC complained that his lawyers were delaying the opportunity to question him. The broadcaster argued that Trump's testimony was necessary to examine the allegations he made in his own lawsuit and to complete the exchange of evidence before the scheduled deadline.

Trump's lawyers denied deliberately obstructing the process, arguing that his presidential responsibilities and security requirements created exceptional scheduling difficulties. According to details of the parties' joint request, his representatives proposed holding the deposition during a period in January when he could be made available for questioning.

The BBC accepted the proposed window, and Kuntz approved the revised schedule. The judge instructed the parties to agree promptly on a specific date and a secure location, establishing an arrangement intended to accommodate the president's official responsibilities while allowing the defendant to question the person who brought the case.

The deposition is expected to last up to seven hours and will be recorded on video, although the recording will be available to the parties' lawyers rather than released publicly. The questioning will take place as part of pretrial discovery and should not be confused with testimony delivered in open court during a trial.

Trump's lawyers have already questioned seven witnesses associated with the defense. Under the latest agreement, they will refrain from taking further depositions of current or former BBC personnel until the president has completed his own questioning. The arrangement also addresses concerns about the sequence of depositions and the time available for both parties to prepare their cases.

The BBC has also sought testimony from members of Trump's family, including Ivanka Trump, Donald Trump Jr. and Jared Kushner. The parties indicated that discussions were continuing over those requests and whether the individuals concerned might challenge the subpoenas. Their eventual participation remains unresolved.

02 / 03

The lawsuit concerns a misleading edit in a Panorama documentary

Trump filed the lawsuit over a BBC Panorama documentary titled Trump: A Second Chance?, broadcast shortly before the 2024 US presidential election. The program combined two passages from a speech Trump gave to supporters before the attack on the US Capitol, presenting comments delivered approximately 55 minutes apart as if they formed one continuous statement.

The resulting sequence created the impression that Trump had directly encouraged supporters to march to the Capitol and engage in violence. The broadcaster subsequently acknowledged that the edit had produced a misleading impression of the original speech and issued an apology to Trump. Senior BBC executives also resigned following the controversy over the documentary's editorial handling.

Trump alleges that the edited segment was defamatory and that its presentation was intended to damage his reputation before the election. His original complaint sought $10 billion in damages across two legal claims, arguing that the broadcaster knowingly misrepresented his remarks and caused substantial reputational and economic harm.

The BBC accepts that the editing fell below its editorial standards but disputes Trump's assertion that the documentary gives rise to an actionable defamation claim. The broadcaster has challenged whether the Florida federal court has jurisdiction over the dispute and whether the president can establish the legally required elements of his allegations.

The distinction between an acknowledged editorial error and legal liability remains central to the proceedings. An apology can establish that a broadcaster recognizes a mistake, while a successful defamation claim requires the plaintiff to satisfy the applicable legal requirements concerning the publication, the defendant's state of mind and any claimed injury.

03 / 03

The defamation claim survives, but the court dismisses a separate allegation

The scheduling extension follows an earlier decision by Kuntz allowing the central defamation allegation to proceed. In his written ruling on the BBC's motion to dismiss, the judge found that Trump's allegations were sufficiently developed to justify further litigation. He rejected the broadcaster's argument that the disputed editing should be treated as ordinary condensation of a lengthy political speech.

Kuntz emphasized the substantial interval between the passages combined in the documentary and the possibility that their presentation changed the meaning conveyed to viewers. The ruling concluded that Trump had adequately pleaded a potential claim for defamation at this stage of the proceedings, permitting the parties to continue gathering evidence.

The judge separately dismissed Trump's claim under the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act. That allegation sought to treat the documentary's publication as conduct covered by the state's consumer protection legislation, but the court concluded that the claim could not proceed under the statute as pleaded.

The decision narrowed the lawsuit while preserving its central dispute over the edited speech. Although the case continues to be described by reference to the $10 billion originally sought, the dismissal of one legal claim means that the initial damages demand should not be interpreted as an amount approved by the court or an indication of what Trump could ultimately recover.

The ruling also expressly left the merits of the surviving allegation unresolved. Trump must still establish the requirements for defamation, including the applicable standard of fault for a public figure and the basis for any recoverable damages. The BBC retains the opportunity to challenge those elements through further motions and at trial.

The president's deposition is a significant part of that process because the defense can question him about his understanding of the documentary, the harm he alleges and evidence supporting his account of its consequences. The extended discovery period gives both sides more time to obtain testimony and documents before the court considers the next stage of the case.

The proceedings remain subject to further motions and possible changes to the trial timetable. The court has allowed the defamation claim to continue without determining whether the BBC is liable, leaving the consequences of the admitted editing error to be resolved through the remaining litigation.

Related

Latest

Reputation Insider

The first media publication dedicated to reputation management, covering industry news and professional practice.