Google faces a November 15 deadline to change how it handles requests to remove personal information from search results under Europe's right-to-be-forgotten rules. The order, issued by the Court of Milan on October 5, requires the company to accept supporting documentation and provide understandable explanations when rejecting requests.
The ruling followed a collective injunction brought by Italian citizens supported by the Algopolio association and represented by law firms LEXIA and ORALEX. According to a statement from LEXIA, the court found that Google's existing procedures restricted users' ability to exercise their rights under European data protection law.
Court orders changes to delisting forms and rejection notices
The court directed Google LLC to modify its procedures so that individuals can attach documents supporting their requests to remove links from search results. When rejecting an application, the company must provide reasons based on an assessment of the material submitted, allowing applicants to understand why their request was unsuccessful.
The proceedings concern Articles 17 and 21 of the General Data Protection Regulation, which govern the right to erasure and the right to object to certain processing of personal data. The applicants challenged what they described as standardized rejection procedures that failed to consider individual circumstances adequately.
Under Google's existing right-to-be-forgotten guidance, applicants must identify the URLs they want delisted and explain their connection to the content. Google says it considers requests individually and may seek additional information before reaching a decision.
Delisting generally restricts the appearance of particular links in search results associated with a person's name. It does not necessarily remove the underlying material from the publisher's website, and requests remain subject to an assessment of privacy rights against the public interest in accessing information.
Google plans appeal as compliance deadline arrives
The October ruling provides for a financial penalty for each day Google fails to comply after the deadline, according to the claimants' published account. The available announcement describes the penalty as substantial but does not specify its amount.
Google disputed the decision and announced plans to appeal. In a statement reported by ANSA, the company defended its review procedures, saying dedicated teams assess individual requests while balancing privacy protections against the public's right to information.
The court's decision concerns the procedures available to applicants rather than a requirement to approve every delisting request. The dispute therefore addresses how users can substantiate their claims and understand refusals, independently of whether particular search results ultimately qualify for removal.
As of November 15, publicly available statements reviewed from the parties and their legal representatives had not confirmed whether Google had implemented the required changes. There was also no verified announcement establishing that the company had missed the deadline or incurred a financial penalty.