Skip to content

Meltwater finds sharp changes in AI search citation patterns

An analysis of 88.6 million citations found that Gemini and Perplexity substantially reduced their source lists, while the visibility of major publishers and social platforms diverged across AI services.

Meltwater finds sharp changes in AI search citation patterns

Meltwater has reported substantial changes in the websites cited by AI search platforms, with Gemini and Perplexity reducing the number of sources included in their answers during October. The findings come from an analysis of approximately 12.7 million AI-generated responses and 88.6 million citations across eight platforms.

The company's October AI search visibility report used Meltwater GenAI Lens to examine roughly 120,000 prompts covering multiple industries and languages. The research included ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews.

01 / 03

Gemini and Perplexity reduce the number of cited sources

Meltwater found that Gemini's average number of links per answer fell from approximately 9.8 to 3.7 beginning around October 15. The change coincided with a 66% decline in the platform's total citations within the tracked dataset.

Perplexity made a comparable adjustment earlier in the month, reducing its source lists from approximately 24 links to a maximum of 10 around October 6. The shorter lists coincided with substantial changes in the relative visibility of individual websites.

Reddit's citations in Gemini fell 88% between the first and second halves of October, exceeding the platform's overall reduction in citations. Its share of Gemini's references declined from 3.6% to 1.3%, while its share in Perplexity increased from 0.9% to 1.4%.

LinkedIn experienced an even more pronounced decline in Perplexity, where its citations fell by approximately 99%. The platform continued to receive citations from other AI services, however, leaving its overall decline across the study at 7.4%.

Despite these changes, Reddit remained the second most-cited domain across the eight platforms. YouTube ranked first, followed by Facebook in third place.

02 / 03

News citations decline as Google AI Overviews cites more social content

The share of citations attributed to news and editorial sources decreased from 31.1% during October 1–15 to 26.8% during October 16–31. Meltwater attributed most of that movement to Perplexity, where the category's share fell from 39.2% to 29.5%.

The other seven AI platforms recorded comparatively modest changes in their use of news sources, with none moving by more than 1.3 percentage points. The findings therefore do not establish a broad decline in news citations across AI services.

Google AI Overviews moved in a different direction for social content. Social platforms accounted for 22.1% of its citations in the second half of October, compared with 19.9% in the first half.

YouTube's share of AI Overview citations increased from 6.7% to 8.2%, while Facebook's rose from 5.1% to 6.1%. These changes differed from Gemini's reduced reliance on the same platforms during the reporting period.

The research also found substantial differences in leading sources between AI services. Wikipedia generated the most citations in Claude and Copilot, while the US National Institutes of Health led ChatGPT's citations and Yahoo remained Perplexity's leading domain.

03 / 03

Expanded methodology limits historical comparisons

Meltwater substantially expanded its research dataset, increasing the number of tracked prompts from approximately 4,000 in previous reports to 120,000. The new sample includes branded queries and a wider range of industries, making direct comparisons with earlier monthly reports unreliable.

For that reason, the October analysis compares the first and second halves of the same month rather than reporting conventional month-over-month changes. The company expects its next report to provide a more consistent comparison using the expanded methodology.

The findings describe citation behavior within the prompts and reporting period examined. They do not establish the quality of AI-generated answers, measure website traffic or demonstrate that the observed changes will persist in subsequent months.

Related

Latest

Reputation Insider

The first media publication dedicated to reputation management, covering industry news and professional practice.