Skip to content

Meta faces sanctions request over evidence withheld in teen mental health cases

Plaintiffs allege Meta improperly withheld or redacted about 93% of documents re-examined in teen mental health lawsuits. They want the jury informed of the alleged misconduct, while Meta denies wrongdoing.

Meta faces sanctions request over evidence withheld in teen mental health cases

Lawyers representing thousands of individuals and school districts have asked a US federal judge to sanction Meta Platforms for allegedly using attorney-client privilege to conceal evidence in lawsuits concerning the effects of Facebook and Instagram on young people's mental health. The request reported by Reuters follows a court-supervised review of internal documents previously withheld or redacted by the company.

The plaintiffs allege that Meta's lawyers improperly protected material relevant to claims that its social media products contributed to addiction and psychological harm among adolescents. Meta disputes the accusations, maintains that it acted in good faith and argues that the sanctions request is an attempt to gain an advantage in the litigation.

01 / 03

Repeated document review raises questions over privilege claims

In a motion filed on November 13, the plaintiffs argued that Meta had applied attorney-client privilege too broadly to internal communications concerning the effects of its platforms on younger users. They accused company lawyers of influencing which records could become available as evidence, potentially limiting the material presented during the proceedings.

Attorney-client privilege generally protects confidential communications made for the purpose of obtaining or providing legal advice. The protection does not automatically extend to every business discussion involving an attorney, making the purpose and content of individual communications relevant to determining whether they can be withheld.

Meta is now re-examining approximately 20,000 documents each week under a court-supervised procedure. According to the plaintiffs, the company has determined during that process that about 93% of the documents reviewed so far were improperly withheld or redacted under its previous privilege classifications.

The percentage concerns documents that have undergone the additional review, rather than every document Meta produced or withheld during the litigation. The figure was presented by the plaintiffs and does not represent a judicial finding that 93% of Meta's evidence was unlawfully concealed.

A court-appointed special master is also examining disputed privilege claims. The document review protocol provides for independent oversight and sets a schedule intended to complete the re-examination by the end of December.

02 / 03

Plaintiffs want jurors informed about the alleged conduct

The plaintiffs have asked US District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, who oversees the consolidated litigation in Oakland, California, to impose sanctions for what they describe as improper handling of evidence. Their proposed remedies would allow jurors to be informed about Meta's alleged conduct during the document disclosure process.

They also want restrictions on the company's ability to challenge their use of material that became available through the renewed review. Such restrictions could affect the presentation of evidence at a trial scheduled for February 2027, although the court has not determined that the requested penalties are justified.

The dispute concerns the availability of internal records that plaintiffs consider relevant to establishing Meta's knowledge of potential risks to children. They contend that earlier privilege designations prevented them from obtaining some of that information during the normal evidence-gathering process.

The latest request follows earlier judicial intervention over Meta's handling of privilege claims. In October, Judge Gonzalez Rogers appointed retired Magistrate Judge Suzanne Segal to oversee aspects of the document review after disagreements over whether the company had properly classified material as protected.

Legal publication Bloomberg Law also reported the sanctions motion, describing accusations that substantial volumes of documents had been withheld through disputed privilege designations. The allegations remain contested, and the filing itself does not establish deliberate misconduct by Meta or its attorneys.

03 / 03

Meta rejects misconduct allegations as litigation continues

Meta's lawyers told the court that the company had acted in good faith when withholding or redacting documents it considered legally privileged. A company spokesperson characterised the sanctions motion as a procedural tactic intended to turn ordinary disputes over evidence disclosure into an advantage at trial.

The company's response disputes the plaintiffs' interpretation of the document review and their allegations about the conduct of its legal team. The available reporting does not establish that the court has accepted the plaintiffs' requested sanctions.

The dispute forms part of federal multidistrict litigation combining claims from families and school districts that social media companies designed products that encouraged compulsive use and contributed to mental health problems among young people. Meta has contested the allegations concerning its platforms and continues to defend itself in the proceedings.

The case is before the US District Court for the Northern District of California under In re Social Media Adolescent Addiction/Personal Injury Products Liability Litigation, case number 4:22-md-03047. Decisions concerning privilege and the proposed sanctions will help determine which documents may be presented to jurors and under what conditions.

The re-examination of documents remains underway, and further disagreements over privilege may still require independent review. The sanctions request has introduced a separate procedural dispute before trial, with its outcome dependent on the judge's assessment of the evidence and the parties' arguments.

Related

Latest

Reputation Insider

The first media publication dedicated to reputation management, covering industry news and professional practice.