NetChoice has filed a federal lawsuit seeking to block a New York law requiring social media platforms to display warnings about the potential mental health effects of excessive use. The trade association, whose members include Meta, Google, TikTok and Snap, argues that the requirement unlawfully compels private companies to communicate the government's position on social media.
The complaint was filed in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York against Attorney General Letitia James, whose office is responsible for enforcing the law. NetChoice is seeking declaratory and injunctive relief before the legislation takes effect on January 1, 2027.
Warning labels would interrupt access to social platforms
New York Governor Kathy Hochul signed the legislation in December 2025, with subsequent amendments defining its scope and display requirements. The law applies to social media services that offer features such as addictive feeds, autoplay or infinite scrolling.
Covered platforms must display a prescribed warning referring to the US Surgeon General's assessment that excessive social media use may be associated with significant mental health harms among young people. The requirements apply to users who have not been determined to be older than 17, meaning platforms may have to display warnings to adults whose ages have not been established.
The initial warning must occupy at least 25% of the screen and remain visible for at least 10 seconds unless the user dismisses it. After three hours of cumulative use, platforms must display another warning for at least 30 seconds, occupying at least 75% of the screen, with further warnings appearing hourly.
These later notices cannot be bypassed before the required display period expires. NetChoice contends that the interruptions restrict access to lawful expression and impose additional burdens on users who wish to avoid age verification.
In its official announcement, the Hochul administration said the legislation was intended to inform families about potential risks associated with platform features that encourage prolonged use. The state has compared the approach with consumer warning requirements used for other products.
NetChoice challenges compelled speech and questions the evidence
NetChoice argues that the First Amendment prohibits the government from requiring private platforms to deliver a prescribed message about a disputed public health issue. The association maintains that the warnings interfere with users' access to protected speech and impose the state's interpretation of scientific evidence on social media companies.
In its case announcement, the organization also questioned whether mandatory warnings would improve adolescent mental health. Those objections form part of the plaintiff's legal position and have not been established as judicial findings in the New York proceedings.
The lawsuit follows a series of similar legal challenges brought by NetChoice against state-level social media regulations. The group filed a comparable complaint against California in October and has challenged warning-label requirements in other states.
NetChoice points to a Colorado federal court decision that blocked a similar law in November 2025 on First Amendment grounds. Colorado has appealed that ruling, and the decision does not determine the outcome of the separate New York case.
According to Reuters, the New York attorney general's office declined immediate comment on the lawsuit. No ruling on the constitutionality of New York's warning-label requirements has been reported.
The law remains scheduled to take effect while the challenge proceeds. Whether NetChoice obtains an injunction will determine if the state can begin enforcing the disputed requirements on the announced date.