Polish President Karol Nawrocki has vetoed legislation that would have introduced national procedures for ordering the removal or blocking of illegal online content. The decision marks his second rejection of measures connected to implementing the European Union's Digital Services Act (DSA), following an earlier veto in January.
The disputed legislation had been revised and approved by parliament in October. It would have given designated authorities powers to issue orders against specific categories of illegal material, subject to judicial review.
President objects to administrative control over online content
In his official statement, Nawrocki argued that government officials should not determine whether online expression constitutes a criminal offence. He maintained that such decisions belong to independent courts and warned that allowing administrative restrictions before judicial review could interfere with freedom of expression.
The president acknowledged that the revised legislation had addressed several objections raised during the previous legislative process. However, he said amendments adopted during the final parliamentary stages had expanded administrative powers over content restrictions beyond what he considered acceptable.
Under the rejected bill, authorities could have ordered restrictions on material involving criminal threats, incitement to violence and certain offences against children. The legislation also provided mechanisms for challenging removal decisions in court and seeking the restoration of content restricted without sufficient grounds.
For the most serious offences, some decisions could have become immediately enforceable following applications from police or prosecutors. The government argued that these provisions were necessary to respond more quickly to material presenting urgent risks.
Government says veto delays enforcement procedures
Poland's Ministry of Digital Affairs criticized the decision, saying it prevented the introduction of faster procedures for restricting illegal material. Digital Affairs Minister Krzysztof Gawkowski argued that the veto left authorities with fewer options for compelling platforms to respond promptly to serious offences.
The ministry also rejected the president's characterization of the legislation as a threat to legitimate expression. It maintained that the proposed orders concerned content prohibited under existing law and included safeguards allowing affected parties to challenge decisions.
The latest dispute concerns one part of Poland's national DSA framework. Following January's veto, the government divided its original legislation into separate measures addressing regulatory oversight and content restriction procedures.
The first measure entered into force on November 6, designating the president of Poland's Office of Electronic Communications (UKE) as the country's Digital Services Coordinator. That legislation established supervisory responsibilities and complaint-handling procedures, while leaving the proposed national system for issuing content-blocking orders to a separate law.
The European Union's DSA remains applicable in Poland despite the presidential veto. The rejected legislation would have provided additional domestic procedures for enforcing particular content restrictions and reviewing platform moderation decisions.
Gawkowski has indicated that the government intends to prepare further legislation. No replacement bill has yet completed the parliamentary process, leaving the disputed administrative removal mechanism unresolved.